Signature Trading Club vs TookThatTradingGroup: which is worth paying for?
Signature Trading Club ranks #21 on signalgroupguide and TookThatTradingGroup ranks #22, so our data already favours Signature Trading Club. That is a starting point, not an answer — the two differ on price, format and who they suit, and the table below is the honest version of the comparison.
Signature Trading Club
€170.00 / month · #21
- Simple, straightforward recurring Whop subscription
- Perfect 5.0 rating from existing reviewers
- Focused specifically on forex signals, not a broad multi-market offering
TookThatTradingGroup
$40.00 / month · #22
- Daily market analysis videos plus live trading calls
- Perspectives from four experienced traders, not just one
- Strong rating (4.95) despite the thin official listing
Side by side
| Signature Trading Club | TookThatTradingGroup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €170.00 / month | $40.00 / month |
| Member rating | 5.0 / 5 (6 reviews) | 5.0 / 5 (15 reviews) |
| Members | 1 | 81 |
| Rank on this site | #21 of 45 | #22 of 45 |
| Best for | Forex traders willing to ask for details before joining | Forex traders wanting daily education from multiple trader perspectives |
| Skip it if | You want a fully documented offer before committing money | You need a fully documented listing before joining |
| Refunds | Set by seller at checkout | Set by seller at checkout |
| Selling on Whop for | about 6 months | 1.3 years |
Where each one falls short
Signature Trading Club
- Description, creator pitch, and FAQ are all blank
- Only 6 reviews and 1 listed member to judge reliability
TookThatTradingGroup
- Official description is very thin on specifics
- Pricing appears to vary by region based on reviewer comments
Choose Signature Trading Club if…
Forex traders willing to ask for details before joining. Skip it if you want a fully documented offer before committing money.
Choose TookThatTradingGroup if…
Forex traders wanting daily education from multiple trader perspectives. Skip it if you need a fully documented listing before joining.
Our take
TookThatTradingGroup has the stronger evidence base of the two — more verified buyers behind its rating, which matters more than the rating itself. Signature Trading Club is the pick if the format or price suits you better; a slightly lower score is not a reason to buy something that does not fit how you work.
Full detail on both: Signature Trading Club review and TookThatTradingGroup review. The wider ranking is in our futures, crypto and forex signal groups table.
Frequently asked questions
Signature Trading Club or TookThatTradingGroup — which is better?
On our blended score Signature Trading Club ranks higher, driven by network conversion data, payout volume and review count. But "better" depends on budget and format: read the "choose this one if" sections, because the two suit different buyers.
Can I join both Signature Trading Club and TookThatTradingGroup?
Yes — they are separate Whop purchases with separate billing, and nothing stops you subscribing to both. Most people are better served picking one, running it for a full billing cycle, and judging it properly before adding a second.
Do you get paid to rank one above the other?
No. Both links are affiliate links and we earn a commission either way, which is exactly why commission rate is excluded from the score. A seller paying 15% can and does outrank one paying 80%.
